I Want Your Approval, But I Don’t Want To Write For It. Sex, striving, and what happens when people you know start reading.

You grow up a certain way, craft a life a certain way. You strive, push, and pursue. You reach for the next rung, no matter what. In swimming, in school, in student council, in “name the category.”

You're congratulated for good grades, so you seek those. You’re told you are thin, in the most congratulatory way, so you seek to remain thin. You are asked, “Why didn’t you just swim faster?” after a disappointing race. And so, you learn, your worth is contingent upon other people's approval.

You must advance to the next rung.

The category itself is nearly meaningless (we'll return to that modifier in a moment). The rung above the current rung is what matters. No matter how many blisters are on your palms, how hard you fight for dear life to maintain your grip, you keep striving.

Everything about your striving is suitable for public consumption. Your parents can brag at work. You can feel good knowing all the grown-ups around you have approved of your pursuits and your performance.

Approval is an enticing elixir.

Then, there's a shift. Not seismic, but not insignificant either. More than she decided to let her grays grow out, but less than she left her husband and ran off with the single mom from her son’s basketball team.

There is still striving, but the path is less worn and less publicly understood. There is no clearing ahead. You’re still yourself, but there’s a noticeable pivot.

And the category, well, this time it does matter. You begin writing openly, nonstop, about desire and sex.

That category catches people’s attention, and the way you write, too. But does it catch their approval?

A Different Kind of Striving

And then, a year ago, we moved, and in the move, my essence moved. Not a 180, but definitely a standard deviation.

I began writing about desire, sex, and long-term love. I began sharing, some things deep and others silly, some traumatic and some erotic. I began putting my messy bits more front and center (do you like that double entendre?) and the curated version more in the background. I allowed my crass side through, my humor, along with my vulnerability and my fears.

Never have I ever opened up this way. My husband learned new things about me after almost two decades, and I learned new things about myself.

I softened a bit. I loosened my rigidity. I cry more. I laugh more. I say the embarrassing thing I used to hold in. I say “I don’t know” more readily. I tell people I’m grateful more often. I hug more fully. I love more freely.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m still me. I still wake up at 5 a.m. to go run. If I don’t, well, no one will be happy about that. I still love a plan, a schedule, a structure. But I’ve moved.

I've leaned further into my understanding and exploration of desire. I believe desire is a right, a part of humanity, a crux of women’s equality. It is an act of political resistance to write and speak so freely, compassionately, and sometimes crassly about desire and sex.

I write unencumbered by knowing who will read.

And then I told everyone about my writing. I went and ruined all this personal growth by sharing with a broad group of friends.

Writing has become a practice I take to with rigor. Free ten minutes? I’m in Google Docs on my phone. A flight, like right now? Open a document and focus. It’s a practice that has turned into a portal. I sit down to write and turn myself into a vessel for the ideas. I try to be the vessel, not the artist. The thing I need to say is already there; I just transport it.

But I shared this pursuit with people I know, and when I sat down to write my most recent article, I was immediately self-monitoring. I was sanitizing my essay before I even got started.

I was thinking, Lindsay will read this. What will she think about that detail? Mark is reading now. It needs to sound smarter, be better. It needs to grab for that next rung. Should I say “fuck” fewer times? Do I really need to describe cum like that?

I was hyperaware, editing before the art was even formed.

I can be graphic, explicit at times. Not gratuitous (IMHO), but detailed. I can write about going down on my husband and fucking an ex who made me feel invisible. I can write about abuse and play over the course of the same 3,000 words.

To date, most of my writing has been for strangers on the internet. Women supporting me from the most amazing web-based cheering section, a few men who gawk and send profane messages (which my colleague assures me means I’m about to make it big), and still fewer men who are delightfully supportive but woefully uninformed.

But these readers were introduced to me as a woman who writes about desire, sex, love, and female sexual agency. And then I invited in a broad network of people who knew the other version of the striver.

Whose brilliant fucking idea was that?

Desire is a Vital Sign

I write about the deeply connective, human, natural, vital sign that is desire. I write about the cultural messages that fucked up the sex lives of so many women and, de facto, so many men.

I write about the trauma that sex can bring and the feral, wild, free, raucous sex that can leave you in a sweaty, sticky pile full of endorphins that I argue cannot be replicated by any other act. I write about still wanting my husband, and all those degrees of wanting. Wanting sweetly and softly and also wanting him to fuck the cognitive load right out of me. I write about the traps of gratitude and competence that highly capable women can fall into, creating lives they’ve always dreamed of that also make them want to escape on the daily.

I “hard launched” my Substack to my sisters (hi!), my cousins (hello!), my dear friends, people who knew me before I started writing, reading, and talking about sex 24/7. I’ve opened up this vulnerable, still-tender side of myself with people who don’t know me like that.

The vulnerability hangover is real.

I sat down to write this article, and what came was a blah-sounding essay starting with, “How much work should a marriage really be?” Yes, this is a decent question and one I may return to in later essays. But not this one. Not now. That’s a sanitized version of what’s really in me and what I want to write for my readers, all of my readers.

I’m a clinician who wants to write so graphically that it disarms the reader. I want the language, the stories, the detail, the research, and the nuance to cause every reader’s head to tilt and eyes to squint.

I want desire and sex to shake us awake and turn us toward awe. I want this to be activism.

I want to share experiences because the more we share, the less alone we all feel. I want to explore why so many couples settle for blah, why people think desire fades, why people recoil at scheduling sex, why cheating is far more common than we know, and why, oh why, sex has moved mountains, caused wars, brought down religions, and yet we still know so little about it, what we like, what we want, and what we deserve.

I want to share it all, unencumbered by who is reading. I want my stories to be our stories. I want them to groundswell into a narrative that says desire is a vital sign, and we have a right to it.

I want to hit publish and say, “Fuck it,” and have people love it or hate it or say politely, “Not for me,” and have it all be okay. I want it to be true, no matter who reads it.

I want to be the vessel.

I’m not writing memoir, although I use my life to write. Amid clinical references, cultural citations, and general musings, I share my lived experience. I am 43. I started having sex at 19. I have been sleeping with the same man for the last 18 years. I did today, and I will do it again tomorrow. We continue to discover and explore new things about one another. We continue to excite one another. We have three wildly wonderful children who sometimes brush their hair and sometimes match their clothes, but always say please and thank you. We have a beautiful life. And desire is a pivotal component of that beauty.

But these stories aren’t only mine. When I write and they escape, my trauma, my joy, my shame, my desire enter the collective.

I shared about negative, sad experiences with an ex, and then his power was gone. I’m sure I'll share about my disordered eating past and my Me Too moments. In the sharing, they are released of any hold over me. These, and all my stories, have brought me to the playful, free, vivacious, lively, deeply, deeply, deeply intimate sex life I currently have. I had to shed the church’s teachings and my people-pleasing ways. I had to live and move through joys and sorrows.

But I can’t please anyone, and I can't release any power if I sanitize this page.

I share because that seems to be the only way I can access the truth. I begin with what I know, what is most raw and true and cringe, and I expand to you, and we, and us. This is likely an ego-driven way of writing, and those who are better, with more skill and creativity, could access an art without centering oneself. I’m sad to say I am not that evolved.

I wish I were.

I'm recognizing that although I am striving and hustling and trying to publish a book on desire and “make it big,” the next rung on that ladder might not be right above.

It might be a hemisphere away.

The next rung might have people in my life going, “What the hell is she doing?” or, “That was a little...interesting.” (Interesting in a Minnesotan, i.e., passive-aggressive, way.)

The next rung might feel like a departure to some. And that needs to be okay. But I’d be lying if I said I didn’t want approval.

I know some people can fully and genuinely not care what other people think. That’s not me. (Another way I’m not as evolved.)

I’d like approval. Shit, I’d like praise. But more than those two things, I want understanding and resonance.

I want readers to understand that I’m trying to thread the needle of writing about desire and sex in a way that doesn’t minimize how connective and intimate it is while also not ignoring the animalistic, feral qualities of it. Both are true. Both deserve space. To embrace the salacious without being gross. To honor the intimacy and importance of sex without disregarding the often challenging logistics.

So, in pursuit of understanding and resonance, I will try to write from my voice, regardless of who is, or is not, reading. Even when it doesn’t sound as smart, as funny, as nuanced, or as poignant as I want. Even when I say “fuck” or “cum” more than my elite, Ivy League education would support.

I will commit to staying true, even when you all are reading, no matter who you are. I will try not to sanitize because, deep down, I think the sanitized words on these pages will lead to less approval, less understanding, and less recognition than the raw, unpolished insides.

So cheers to these unsanitized pages.

I hope you find resonance.

Previous
Previous

The Case for Fucking Through the Chaos. Sex is More Than a Feel-Good Moment

Next
Next

The Language of Desire: Can the Words We Use Change Our Sex Lives?