Love is a whole-person, mind-body fuck. It demands all of us, every single part.
We are embodied beings. We touch and smell and move. We have magnetism and chemistry, voices and skin, gestures and glances. Our bodies are not merely containers for our more meaningful parts. They are part of how we experience one another and how we imprint the memories of our lives.
Our bodies move through time and space, cultures and environments. They are not less important than our brains, our emotions, or our feelings. They are not more important either. They are part of a whole. All of our messy human pieces move within our ecosystem, occasionally encountering another ecosystem and, sometimes, creating this thing called love.
It’s not blind. My love is not blind.
I want my full self to be seen, heard, embraced, touched, caressed, wanted, and needed. I want to be exposed under the bright fluorescent lights of vulnerability and still have someone looking directly at me...with love. I want my partner to want my body and my mind; to want to touch me and listen to me; to feel my skin and soothe my pain; to be connected to me, literally and metaphorically.
The Show
My husband and I watch Love Is Blind together. I am not proud of this and neither is he. I reveal intimate details of our sex life in my essays, and this might be the detail that makes him wince the most!
It’s our brain candy after a long day. Intellectual stimulation it is not. Love Is Blind is the Twinkie of television. Why does it even exist? Is it made of real food? How can it possibly be shelf-stable for that long? There must be something wrong with it.
That’s how I feel about Love Is Blind. There must be something wrong with it. So, as the curious, sex-on-the-brain, depraved writer that I am, I got curious:
What, exactly, is wrong with Love Is Blind?
Why do these couples spend days talking through a purple wall, becoming convinced they’ve found the person they want to marry, the person they feel most “safe” with on the entire planet (although I think most of them are defining “safe” inaccurately), get engaged, and then develop irreparable problems within 48 hours of occupying the same physical space?
If they manage to last beyond the first 48 hours, the cracks become chasms when they meet the other people they dated in the pods, go back to work, hear the opinions of their friends and family, and, duh duh duh...get their phones back. The ultimate saboteur.
Yet season after season, after all the drama-filled ridiculousness and another reunion in which we learn just how spectacularly some of these relationships imploded, Nick and Vanessa return to the pods and ask another group of eager, wide-eyed singles the same question: Is love truly blind? People continue to sign up for this “experiment” with the hope that the hypothesis that love is indeed truly blind will be confirmed.
But the data tells them it’s a disaster. So why do they keep signing up?
Yes, yes. Capitalism. I’m sure that’s 99% of the answer. Netflix would stop asking the question if we stopped watching them ask it. (I know, I’m the problem, it’s me). But what about the other 1%?
Why is the premise so seductive?
Inside all the gold goblets, vulnerable sharing, “are they here for the right reasons?” and dramatic reveals, is an idea we are genuinely drawn to: that if we could somehow strip away the superficial trappings, we could discover another person’s real self. That love might actually become purer if bodies, appearances, environments, cultures, and ordinary life stopped getting in the way.
This is what the premise gets fundamentally wrong about being human. The pods don’t only make people blind to appearance and attraction. They make them blind to one another as embodied human beings living in the world. They make them blind to context.
We don’t exist in isolation. We exist in bodies, in homes, at work, among friends and family, within cultures and communities. We are shaped by religions and parents and pickleball leagues. We’re humans who load dishwashers, floss (sometimes), spend too much time on our phones, get road rage, keep vegan diets, wake up at 5am, travel for work, stay out too late at the bar, have that ex who you just can’t understand was ever part of their lives, stress about student debt, dream of children with backyards and playsets, and wonder whether we will ever be enough.
This is the stuff of a life. We fall in love with people within that life, within the constructs of society, and within bodies.
The pods don’t just remove the supposedly “superficial” element of physical attraction, which I argue isn’t entirely superficial anyway. They remove context.
For those few days, participants are plucked out of their lives and placed into an alternate reality. We don’t see how they navigate their worlds. They become avatars; flattened 2-dimensional depictions of a dating profile.
Context isn’t a distraction from who someone really is. Context is part of who someone really is, but the pods only reveal the 2-D versions.
Musical Chairs
There is something else happening in the pods: a giant game of romantic musical chairs.
As the music plays, the anxiety mounts. Every bar played brings the person closer to the moment the music will stop, and everyone knows there’s one fewer chair than there are people. So everyone walks faster, turning into a hip-shimmying speed-walker around the corners of the chair loop, as if walking faster will change the constraints of the game. But someone will always be left standing.
When the music stops, all hell breaks loose. Panic to claim a seat ensues, and elation or devastation results.
That same pressure exists on Love Is Blind. Except the chair is a fiancé.
The “experiment” creates a fixed pool of potential partners, compresses the timeline, adds competition, and creates an impending requirement to choose. You don’t just want to marry another person, you also don’t want to be left without a chair.
That scarcity changes how the participants think and behave.
If participants spent ten days talking in the pods and were then offered the opportunity to continue dating in the outside world, I suspect the outcomes would look very different. Instead, the structure manufactures urgency and then asks them to interpret the resulting intensity as love.
This is an established dynamic: situations shape behaviour. Put people inside an artificial environment, give them roles, rules, scarcity, competition, and a timeline, and they behave differently than they might outside of that artificial environment. Love Is Blind is an artificial pressure cooker.
The Reveal
Then, if they do get engaged, they finally meet.
I love the first meeting, the reveal. Some couples kiss with passion and what appears to be palpable chemistry. Others give a cheek kiss and hug like siblings. Still others behave so awkwardly that you can almost see them, in real time, trying to reconcile the voice behind the wall with the face and body now standing in front of them.
The reveal is, in fact, revealing.
An enormous amount of new information has just arrived. The voice now has a body. It moves and smells and touches. It has facial expressions and gestures, a way of kissing and holding another person, a physical energy that didn’t exist through the wall. We watch the participants try to integrate all of that data, some more successfully than others.
And the resulting shift isn’t necessarily as superficial as we sometimes assume. It’s not simply that someone weighs five pounds more than hoped or has brown hair instead of blond. It’s not evidence that physical cues have somehow contaminated a purer emotional connection, or that they’re all vapid, looks-driven egomaniacs (though some of them certainly are).
It’s evidence that our emotions aren’t separate from the physical bodies and spaces we occupy. All of these different parts of us interact with and influence one another. They cannot be neatly compartmentalised or placed into a hierarchy of value, try as we might.
After the reveal, the couples spend a few days on a mini getaway before they’re plopped back into reality, where they discover even more things about one another that they couldn’t possibly have known through a wall.
First comes the disembodied connection, then the body, then the rest of life.
Blindness Is About More Than Looks
If someone says, “I’ll only date a model with these exact measurements,” sure, that person is gross, vapid, immature, and superficial. We agree. But acknowledging that we are embodied beings is not the same thing as reducing another human being to their appearance.
Physical attraction and falling in love with a disembodied consciousness are not the only two options. When you remove the body, you don’t just remove looks. You remove smell, movement, touch, facial expressions. The way someone occupies space, how they interact with a barista, how they hold your hand, whether their energy settles or activates you. How they look at you when you say something ridiculous or have food in your teeth. How they respond when you reach for them.
You remove the thousands of tiny pieces of information our bodies are constantly exchanging with another human being. So why do we think these facets of interaction and connection are less true or meaningful? Our bodies don’t obscure a deeper, more authentic connection, they’re part of creating it.
Attraction Is Complicated
To be fair to Love Is Blind, the premise isn’t entirely ridiculous. Looks do influence how we perceive people, often in ways we don’t recognise.
The attractiveness halo effect, our tendency to attribute other positive qualities to people we perceive as physically attractive, is a well-researched phenomenon. We don’t just think hot people are hot. We also assume they’re more intelligent, trustworthy, socially competent, successful, and kind. Physical appearance can shape our impressions before we know much of anything else about a person.¹
Attraction is complicated. We have cultural ideas about what is “objectively” attractive, but those ideals change over time, a pretty clear indication that they’re anything but objective. Heroin chic gave way to big booties, which are now giving way to Ozempic thin. Trends change. Attraction is neither objective nor universal. What draws one person towards another is far messier and more individual than a culturally sanctioned list of desirable physical traits.
So maybe Love Is Blind is asking a worthwhile question, just not the right one.
Instead of asking whether we can eliminate appearance in order to find someone’s “real” self, maybe we should be asking how aware we are of the assumptions we make based on physical appearance. Am I attracted to this person, or am I assigning them qualities they haven’t actually demonstrated because I find them attractive? Am I dismissing someone because they don’t fit an ideal I’ve absorbed about what is supposed to be attractive?
These questions ask us to become more curious about our attraction, rather than pretending we can remove it entirely.
Most of us have had the experience of meeting someone who is “objectively” good-looking, only to get to know them and become intensely repelled. That person moves from hot to utterly unfuckable. The opposite happens too. Someone doesn’t immediately strike us as attractive, so they get friend-zoned. But over time, we realise they’re kind or funny, a little quirky, attentive, and genuine. We start to feel something; they become sexy to us.
It goes both ways because attraction isn’t happening separately from everything else we’re learning about a person. All of that information is continually changing how we experience them. It’s all in the context.
The Guy in the Grocery Store
I met my husband in a grocery store. Sort of. We eventually met online, but the first time I saw him, we were browsing the aisles of Ralphs.
I thought he was hot. But that wasn’t the only thing I noticed.
He was wearing a UCLA hat backwards. Good school, with a little bit of edge. He had vegetables in his cart. A real, grown-ass man feeding himself vegetables and cooking them for himself. He was polite and affable with the checkout person. He actively bagged his own groceries instead of standing there waiting for someone else to do it for him. Not to mention, this was all occurring in the same grocery store I shopped in, so he likely lived close by. Convenience is nice!
None of this meant anything definitive. Vegetables do not a good husband make, or even a first date. A backwards hat is not a validated measure of emotional intelligence.
But I was taking him in. His face and body were part of the information I was receiving, but so was everything else. How he moved, what he bought, how he treated another person, how he occupied the space around him. I liked what I saw, and not simply because I thought he was sexy.
Eventually, we met, and I got more information.
That is how attraction works in the real world. We encounter another person and begin gathering thousands of tiny pieces of data. Some conscious, some unconscious. Some physical, some social, some emotional. Some of our first impressions turn out to be right and others wildly wrong. We keep learning, adjusting, and discovering.
I didn’t marry him two weeks later. I became curious about him and dated him. We talked and hung out and hooked up and gathered data, day upon day, date upon date. I learned that he really liked my dog. I also discovered another grocery-store behaviour of his once things got serious enough that we started shopping together.
If we were standing in line and one of us realised we’d forgotten something, he refused to hold our place while the other person ran to grab it. He thought that was unjust. You forget an item, you step out of line and go to the back, even if there are two of you and you could easily split up.
His sense of justice only made him sexier in my eyes. We revealed ourselves to one another within our lives, remaining curious and open.
The problem with Love Is Blind isn’t that people can’t develop meaningful feelings without seeing one another. Clearly, they can. The problem is that the show takes one narrow stream of information, intensifies it through isolation, scarcity, competition, and time pressure, and then asks participants to make an enormous decision before most of the information that ordinarily shapes human attachment has even arrived.
I don’t want to be loved despite all the information. I want to be loved as the information keeps arriving, as bodies and lives change. As we learn things about each other we couldn’t possibly have known through a wall, across a first date, or even after fifteen years together.
I don’t want a love protected from reality. I want one that keeps encountering reality, removing purple wall after purple wall as we continue discovering one another within the context of our lives.
Let’s love with our eyes open.
References
1. Karen Dion, Ellen Berscheid, and Elaine Walster, “What Is Beautiful Is Good,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 24, no. 3 (1972): 285–290, doi:10.1037/h0033731; Carlota Batres et al., “What Is Beautiful Is Still Good: The Attractiveness Halo Effect in the Era of Beauty Filters,” Royal Society Open Science (2024).