The Audacity NOT to Dream. The Intersection of Our Erotic Selves and Possible Selves

Have you ever scared yourself with a nearly inconceivable desire? So much so that the fear of everyone else’s judgment is eclipsed only by your own?

Have you ever dared to dream a cyclone of delusion that only a psychosis could spin up?

Have you ever dared to believe in yourself to the extent of (un)becoming everything you never knew you wanted?

Have you ever dared to stop lying to your journal and your therapist and your bestie and your other therapist?

Have you ever dared to reveal yourself to a lover so graphically and recklessly that you risk extinguishing all the flames of lust, in hopes that it might ignite a wildfire?

Have you ever dared to say your dream out loud, in public, despite the tremble in your voice and the terror of their reaction? Unveiling your insides like a priceless work of art, hoping for gasps and oohs and ahhs, but bracing for silence and whispers?

Have you ever yearned, not for success or fame or glory or a person or a love, but for a readiness? A readiness that says, “right now I am a chrysalis, and tomorrow I will fucking fly.”

Have you ever pushed your child on a swing at the park in the middle of the day? Your mind nowhere near that park, fully entranced by the rhythm of the pushing, a rhythm reminiscent of that time he leaned you over the bathroom sink? Push…push…push…push….

Have you ever greeted your partner with a pressure and passion in your kiss that refused to weaken despite your decades together? A kiss that says this has nothing to do with love and everything to do with want.

Have you ever cut the crusts off a sandwich while fantasizing about cutting the crusts off your own cognition, blocking your busy mind and moving into your wanting body?

I want these dreams for you.

I want settled, manicured, organized, typical lives to turn gold with shimmery nuance. I want the boring mundane of midlife to become the mundane of a life you inhabit with passion rather than one you accept with a half-smile and a resigned “I’m fine.”

We live in the mundane, not in the vacations or the “when the kids are out of the house...” We are alive now, capable of transforming our mundane into our dreams.

We must be willing to exist in the excruciating purgatory of “not this, but not yet the next thing.” The space between knowing what we want and having the courage, means, privilege, and opportunity to pursue it is torturous.

But the pain of purgatory is far less than the alternative. The pain of numbing our audacious dreams, shelving them when we have kids, when we hit midlife, or because we should be grateful and leave well enough alone? That pain is existential.

How Audacious…

A few weeks ago, questioning the audacity of my dreams, I spoke with a woman who said something I haven’t stopped thinking about. She said:

“Your dream might feel audacious, but how audacious would it be of you NOT to pursue that which is screaming from within you? How audacious would it be to reject your wild dream?”

I had been so focused on whether my dreams were too audacious that I hadn’t considered the audacity of denying them.

We’re pretty good at calculating the risks of pursuing dreams, but not often the risks of refusing them.

Is it audacious of me to desire so boldly and freely that I scare myself, or is it audacious of me to stifle my dream?

Our Erotic Selves

Our capacities to dream and to desire, to experience the full expansiveness of what it means to be alive, are coded into the DNA of our erotic selves.

Eroticism is a state of awakeness. It’s not bleary-eyed or hungover, moving through the world mostly-asleep, watching the clock slowly tick. It’s bright-eyed, alert, and alive to possibility. It’s welcoming the full force of our desires without trying to tame them.

It might open us up to more pain, but it also opens us up to more pleasure.

A lot of us narrowly associate eroticism with sexual behavior, but the erotic is far greater. It’s our capacity to breathe deeply in the world around us, to be moved by connection, to feel a hunger, to crave and yearn and seek, to experience ourselves as forever capable of discovery.

Possibility is erotic. Imagining ourselves beyond our current circumstances, anticipating what might come next; what is more tantalizing? Our erotic experience exists in the space between imagination and reality. This is also the space of our dreams.

Courage to pursue our dreams and courage to embrace our sexuality are borne from the same source. Both require an embrace of wanting, even when wanting threatens the curated identities we’ve constructed. Our real audacity is more than having dreams. Our real audacity is living our dreams.

Our Possible Selves

Embracing desire, passion, and pleasure requires our capacity to ask, “What else?”

In 1986, psychologists H. Markus and P. Nurius introduced the concept of possible selves.¹ They explored what we imagine, what we hope to become, and also what we fear becoming. They wanted to understand how our imagined selves can shape our motivation and behavior. They asserted that we are not limited to our present identities, but rather, we carry imagined versions of ourselves in our minds that can shape who we might become.

Our capacity to imagine is influenced by our environment and what we observe to be allowable or realistic. Imagining that which we have never seen requires a level of imagination only fantasies can manifest.

Women dream. Their whole lives long, women dream. But far too often, within a constrained choice set. We dream of our children flourishing in their own relationships and careers, our families creating holiday cards year after year with genuine smiles and earnest connection, and of our loves lasting the tests of time. These are wonderful and worthy dreams. But women also have dreams that disrupt the constraints of this choice set.

These dreams might begin to poke at our current circumstances, feeling more like straitjackets than security. We might dismiss our desires before we’ve even allowed ourselves to acknowledge them because the jacket’s constriction cuts off blood flow to the imagination; its tightness feels less like a warm embrace and more like a smothering.

We women, we also have an irritating, self-defeating tendency of policing our own wanting before anyone else can reject it. We’ve internalized so many expectations about what it means to be good mothers, supportive partners, and respectable women that our own desires are far too threatening to entertain.

We tell ourselves we should be grateful, but joke’s on us, because gratitude was never meant to be the abandonment of desire. Gratitude has shape-shifted into another mechanism of control.

We can love the lives we’ve built and still want more; a complete rejection of our current identity is not the price of admission for imagining more. Dreams need not be justified by dissatisfaction or rock bottom.

This is where our erotic selves and our possible selves meet, within our capacity to imagine.

Our possible selves help us understand how imagined futures shape who we might become. Our erotic selves beckon possibility through longing and the sensation of being alive to a reality beyond the present.

Desire can be an unsettling realization that there is something else we want. It can feel like a dream entirely incompatible with the person everyone believes we are, including ourselves; but an incompatibility with our current identity is not cause for erasure.

I hope our unsettling, scary, inconvenient, and incomprehensible desires are the ones to which we all succumb. I want women to explore their possible selves with full abandon. I wish for our greatest delusion to be believing that the lives we currently inhabit are the only lives we’re capable of living.

I wish for us to be audacious.

References

  1. Markus, H., & Nurius, P. (1986). Possible selves. American Psychologist, 41(9), 954–969.

Next
Next

Who Cares How Often You Have Sex? I Do. The arbitrary definition of a sexless marriage and why sexual frequency still matters.