“You’ll bleed from your vagina, but it doesn’t mean you’re dying.”
Thank you, Sister Josephine, for my thorough sex education (or lack thereof).
Sex education that teaches young women and girls about their bodies, sexual health, reproduction, relationships, communication, consent, desire, pleasure, and their own sexual agency should be the standard we’re striving for, not whatever you call the talk I received in fifth grade.
Unfortunately, while comprehensive sex education does exist, its content, quality, and implementation vary widely, and pleasure remains glaringly absent from many curricula.
Pleasure isn’t only about sexual satisfaction. It also has direct implications for safety. Rooted in cultural narratives and policies that have historically constrained female sexuality and pleasure, sex education has largely been taught through a myopic lens of what could go wrong, what girls should prevent, and what they must try to manage.
Girls are taught what their bodies might provoke in others so they can defend against it, but they aren’t taught, and certainly aren’t empowered, to consider what their bodies can do for themselves. Girls learn that they’re supposed to say “no” to most sexual activities, but not what they might want to say “yes” to.
Sister Josephine’s Sex Ed.
In addition to learning about my bloody, but not deadly, vagina, I was told not to get pregnant. What caused pregnancy, though, I’m not sure I knew.
I learned nothing about my anatomy, male anatomy, condoms, erections, arousal, or, sadly, consent, safety, and pleasure.
I was taught abstinence. Abstinence from what, again, was still unclear. I eventually deduced that the nuns were defining sex as penis-in-vagina penetration, and that was the activity I was not supposed to partake in. Until marriage.
My public school friends received a version of the safe sex talk that included condom use, the conditions necessary for pregnancy, and sexually transmitted infections (STDs, as we called them at the time). They learned more than I did, but none of us received a thorough education.
Research has consistently challenged the assumptions underlying the type of education I received. A 2023 systematic review of 29 studies found that comprehensive sex education likely reduced adolescent pregnancy and improved safer-sex behaviours.¹ The evidence did not support the assumption that withholding information makes young people safer.
But even when we provide information about pregnancy, contraception, and infections, we are still leaving out a fundamental component of sex education:
Pleasure.
The Gray Zone Between Consent and Desire
Planned Parenthood improved on the education, offering one of the most thorough models of consent, FRIES:
Freely Given
Reversible
Informed
Enthusiastic
Specific
We’ve come a long way since my early ‘90s education. But the “I” in FRIES keeps bringing me back to two questions: How informed are we about sex itself? Not only the mechanics and the risks, but the possibilities, our preferences, and our right to decide what we want from an experience?
Understanding what we’re agreeing to is essential for consent. Knowing what we want and what we have a right to expect from sexual experiences helps us exercise agency. When pleasure is absent from sex education, we risk adopting ideas about what sex is supposed to look like rather than actively pursuing and communicating what we desire.
Sexual boundaries are typically presented in a binary, a “yes” or a “no.” But what I hear, what I read, and what I know from my own experiences is that boundaries are sometimes gray. In this gray, it can become frighteningly difficult to distinguish between what we’re freely choosing, what we’re tolerating, and what we’re doing because we believe we’re supposed to.
The line between experimenting, trying new things, being a generous lover, taking turns, and waiting for responsive desire to “kick in” can become blurred. We can find ourselves moving toward an edge where we’re doing things we don’t want to do to keep the peace, to get things over with, or to stay psychologically or physically safe.
As an example, I’m growing increasingly uncomfortable with how we treat the framework of responsive desire in sound bites.
I’ve written about responsive desire before, and will likely write about it again. Understanding responsive desire has been revolutionary, even life-altering, for many people, particularly women, who have discovered that sexual desire doesn’t necessarily precede sexual activity. It can commence after intimate activity begins, allowing women to enjoy fulfilling sex lives without waiting for spontaneous desire to appear.
However, when someone begins sexual activity expecting responsive desire to emerge, the space between willingness and obligation can become blurry. We begin a sexual encounter assuming that our desire will enter the room. But what if it doesn’t? What if it never comes?
I know women for whom this happens. They begin, expecting desire to turn on, but it doesn’t. They don’t stop. They don’t say, “Hey, I’m not feeling it today.” They keep going, having duty sex, not enjoying themselves, performing what they believe is expected of them.
I’m not arguing this is a violation of consent or a boundary crossed. But I am saying it’s ambiguous, and I’m not sure what to call it. Is this an act of love? An act of self-betrayal? Or something else entirely?
There’s no one answer that applies to every person or every encounter. People can choose sex for reasons other than their own immediate pleasure. Distinguishing between generosity and obligation is important, just as recognizing when we’re giving ourselves an opportunity to become aroused versus overriding our own lack of desire is essential.
We can’t examine these situations without acknowledging the cultural expectations women carry into sexual encounters. We’re socialized to be accommodating, generous, and attentive to the needs of others, because god forbid we ever disappoint.
A woman can genuinely enjoy giving pleasure to her partner, even when she isn’t particularly interested in receiving pleasure herself. That can be a loving and satisfying experience. A woman can also participate in sex because she believes that being a good wife, girlfriend, or lover requires it, regardless of how she feels. She can cross an internal boundary in service of an external expectation.
So What Are We Consenting To?
Are we consenting to vaginal penetration? Are we consenting to anal penetration, oral sex, rough sex, being watched, being filmed and then shared, being blindfolded, being held down, moaning, spitting, being tied up, kissing, having our hair pulled, having an orgasm, making sure someone else has an orgasm?
Are we consenting to getting on our knees while someone pushes our head down? To gagging while we’re told to keep going? To sex without enough lubrication, when we’re so raw it hurts? To a gentle kiss we don’t want? To rolling over afterward, left in a mess, while they leave?
Are we consenting to an orgasm that quakes our body and brings tears to our eyes? Multiple orgasms, back to back? To the thrill of being held down by someone we trust and desperately want? To butterflies that take flight with passionate kisses, turning into sensual touches, into sweet, deep moans? Fingers, tongues, mouths? Licks that make us tremble? A pleasure of being utterly devoured by another? Or fun and frolicking in the sheets that turn sticky and silly and just plain ridiculous? A moment we’ll remember for the rest of our lives?
What are we consenting to?
I’m not being explicit for clicks. I’m being explicit because if we’re refusing to name what sex might involve, how do we ensure our consent is informed?
None of the activities described are inherently pleasurable or degrading. Being held down can be deeply intimate when it’s wanted and terrifying when it isn’t. A gentle kiss can be inappropriate. An orgasm can occur during an experience someone never consented to, and an encounter without an orgasm can be remarkably satisfying.
The activity itself doesn’t tell us whether someone is experiencing pleasure, exercising agency, or having their boundaries violated. What matters is whether they engage in those activities freely and with an informed understanding of their own wants and desires.
I know how complicated this can be.
I began consenting to sex at 19. I sure as shit can tell you I had no idea what I was consenting to. I was consenting to doing whatever the guy I was desperately trying to get to like me wanted me to do. If he was willing to call me his girlfriend, I was “game” for anything.
For the most part, I came out of those early, uninformed, uneducated sexual encounters unscathed. But there were certainly some blurry boundaries where what I was doing shifted from generosity and experimentation to a betrayal of my own comfort and desires.
It was not sexual assault. It was not nonconsensual contact. But I cannot look back on those experiences and say I was exercising informed sexual agency.
For the most part, I happened upon safe sex. I happened upon pleasurable sex.
Are we really okay with raising our daughters to simply hope they’ll have consensual, safe, and pleasurable sex? I’m not.
Pleasure education won’t determine whether consent exists. We can consent to something that turns out not to be pleasurable, and our bodies can also respond physically to experiences we haven’t consented to. But teaching women to consider what they might enjoy and what they are entitled to expect gives them a stronger foundation for recognizing and communicating their boundaries.
Pleasure Is Not Frivolous
We’re comfortable (sort of) discussing what happens to women’s bodies during sex, but not what women might want to happen to their bodies. Pregnancy, menstruation, reproduction, disease, and danger are legitimate subjects. A woman’s desire for pleasure, her interest in her own arousal, and her pursuit of orgasm are still unacceptable.
Sex education researchers Kristen Mark, Esther Corona-Vargas, and Mariana Cruz have argued that excluding pleasure from comprehensive sexuality education can undermine sexual development and miss opportunities to support sexual well-being. They identify six areas that could benefit from integrating pleasure: risk reduction, healthy relationships, sexual diversity, sexual rights, empowerment and consent, and prevention of gender-based sexual violence.² There’s also evidence that incorporating pleasure into sexual health interventions can improve safety outcomes. A 2022 review found a significant positive effect on condom use in interventions that incorporated sexual pleasure.³
We’ve treated pleasure as a distraction from safety when it can help us achieve the very outcomes we claim to seek. But pleasure education isn’t necessary only because it might improve safety or health outcomes. Pleasure is a worthy pursuit in its own right, no proof of utility required.
Pleasure is part of being human. It’s part of how we experience our bodies and our relationships. We recognize its importance in music, food, art, movement, and play. We don’t demand that these experiences prevent disease or improve public safety before considering them worthy.
When we teach girls that their pleasure matters, we’re challenging a long history of treating women’s sexuality as something that exists for someone else’s benefit. We’re telling them that sex is not simply something that happens to them or something they provide to another person. They have desires of their own, and those desires deserve consideration.
I want young people to know how to prevent unwanted pregnancy, coercion, and infection. I also want them to understand that sex can be joyful, intimate, exciting, playful, and pleasurable. They get to be curious about what they enjoy. They can communicate what they want. They can change their minds.
“If the Game’s Not Working for One Person, It’s Not Working for Anyone.”
Sister Josephine meant no harm. I think she was probably one of the good nuns who believed in kindness, inclusivity, and the anti-establishment Jesus.
But her teachings were so incomplete that they weren’t just rendered unhelpful; they left voids that were filled by confusion, misinformation, and shame. The absence of information wasn’t the absence of learning.
My children are 8, 10, and almost 12. Since they were old enough to form words, they’ve known the correct names for their anatomy: vagina, labia, penis, nipples, and so on. They know that their bodies will change and develop, and that new sensations and feelings are a normal part of growing up, a normal function of their bodies, and a way to know that their bodies are developing as they should.
They understand that no one is entitled to touch their bodies without permission. When a doctor needs to examine them, we explain what’s happening, and I’m there to support them.
They know sex is not simply a penis entering a vagina. They know there are different ways to make a baby, that sexual activity carries risks, and that when they’re older, their father and I hope that sex is a joyful part of their lives. I want them to be safe, and I want them to have the knowledge to enjoy this part of their lives if and when they choose to.
When they were younger, and a game ended in someone’s tears, we would say, “Okay, the game is broken. If it’s not working for one person, it’s not working for anyone.”
These were conversations over Lego and superheroes, long before sex entered the picture. But they were the beginnings of an education about consent, pleasure, and mutuality. Just because one person is enjoying the game doesn’t mean it’s working for everyone, and when the game stops being fun for one person, the game stops.
As my children get older and their understanding of relationships, bodies, and sexuality becomes more sophisticated, I want them to grow up understanding that pleasure isn’t shameful or selfish, that caring about another person’s pleasure doesn’t require sacrificing their own, and that sex is not an obligation to be fulfilled or a performance to be perfected.
I want them to have the information I didn’t have. I want them to be able to ask questions without embarrassment, to recognize when something doesn’t feel right, to be happy when something does feel right, and to know that their own enjoyment is a legitimate consideration in deciding whether, when, and how to engage in sexual activity.
Footnotes
Bordogna, Amy L., Amanda C. Coyle, Rupa Nallamothu, Alina L. Manko, and Renata W. Yen. “Comprehensive Sexuality Education to Reduce Pregnancy and STIs in Adolescents in the United States: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.” American Journal of Sexuality Education 18, no. 1 (2023): 39–83.
Mark, Kristen, Esther Corona-Vargas, and Mariana Cruz. “Integrating Sexual Pleasure for Quality & Inclusive Comprehensive Sexuality Education.” International Journal of Sexual Health 33, no. 4 (2021): 555–564.
“What Is the Added Value of Incorporating Pleasure in Sexual Health Interventions? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis.” PLOS ONE (2022). The analysis of eight studies, involving 6,634 participants at baseline, found a moderate positive effect on condom use (Cohen’s d = 0.37, 95% CI 0.20–0.54).