Performance: Is My Sexual Desire Actually Mine? The sexual scripts we mistake for our own desires

The Cool Girl.

That’s the girl I performed for years.

The script called for a girl who was confident in her body. Or, more accurately, a girl who looked confident in her body. (Because I was under the false impression that sexiness was entirely about the appearance of my body.)

The Cool Girl wasn’t hypervigilant about her body size, shape, or weight. Definitely not distracted by how she appeared. We all know the girl who fiddles with her hair every few seconds, adjusting how it falls over her shoulder. She’s hot, but the constant rearranging, making it flop just so across her collarbone, is a tell. She’s beautiful, but she’s trying. She’s performing.

The Cool Girl looked sexy, but she wasn’t preoccupied with looking sexy.

She wasn’t insecure about boobs she thought were far too small to warrant anyone’s attention, shoulders too broad from years of swimming, or a face too marked from over-picking. She effortlessly floated from the keg to the dance floor, over to the couch, and then to the bar, not adjusting her hair or jeans too often. She flitted from conversation to conversation with a spark and a side-eye (paired with the strategically exposed side-boob) that said, You’re into me. I know it, you know it, we all know it. Just embrace it.

The script called for a girl who was “up for anything.” A girl who could hook up and keep it casual because that’s what cool girls did. Cool girls didn’t want relationships.

She went to the parties and drank beer and whiskey. She watched football and cheered her man on while he played Halo with his friends, paying absolutely no attention to her. But she didn’t mind; he was having fun.

She was chill after a text. She certainly never sent one first. She was totally down to hang out when an invitation arrived hours into the evening, assuredly a few drinks deep, for a meetup just fifteen minutes later.

The script did not call for a girl who wanted a real date, or a meal, or advance notice of said date. It didn’t call for a girl who wanted the label girlfriend. Or, god forbid, to be acknowledged as one in public. And it certainly didn’t call for her to expect a guy who gave a damn about her pleasure during sex.

That was The Cool Girl part. Who wouldn’t want to play that role? (Fuck that. That role was awful.)

There was no glory in that role, almost nothing in it for the girl, but I was eager to play her, and I wasn’t the only one.

There were also the specific sexual behaviors that came with the role. Same character, same script, different scenes.

Be up for anything. Consent to everything. Don’t say “I love you.” Be cool with not having an orgasm. Be cool with no condom because guys don’t like condoms. Be cool with no exclusivity because it’s overrated anyway. Be cool giving oral sex without receiving it. Be cool when he comes in your mouth without warning. Be cool when he pulls out and comes on your tits without asking. Be cool when he comes inside you without a condom, without telling you he was going to. It’s what he likes. Be cool when he won’t call you his girlfriend because you know what he’s like when it’s just the two of you. He’s so dreamy when it’s just the two of you.

Be cool; be good at sex; be good at pleasing. Be cool with whatever he wants and ask for nothing you want.

I was pretty good at playing the Cool Girl. Well, certain aspects of her. I performed well sexually, but I was considerably less successful at pretending I didn’t want a relationship.

I wanted to be a girlfriend, in public. I wanted to matter outside the bedroom, to meet his friends and his parents, to hold hands and kiss in public.

The Afternoon in Venice

He came inside me without a condom, and I was cool with it.

I liked this guy. A lot. We weren’t exclusive, but I was hoping we would be.

I had never had condom-free sex with someone I wasn’t exclusive with. But this guy, well, I hoped we would become exclusive. And I thought, Maybe it will make him like me more this way. Maybe he’ll decide he wants to be exclusive because the sex with me is better.

(I know...I can hear your sighs and see the eye-rolls through the screen.)

Condom or not, the difference in sensation was meaningless to me. But it mattered to him, so I was cool with it.

We had penetrative sex, he came inside me, and after the cleanup, the getting dressed, and the I’ll-text-you-laters, he left my apartment.

I promptly sat down at the desk in my room, opened my laptop, and googled where I could get Plan B. After a few clicks, I was clear. I grabbed my car keys, walked down the stairs, and drove myself to the Walgreens at the corner of Lincoln and Washington in Venice Beach. I walked to the back of the store where the pharmacy counter was, stood in line, and quietly asked for Plan B.

I was ashamed.

I was not ashamed of getting Plan B. I thought Plan B was an incredible resource, one that should be freely and easily accessible. I was ashamed that I needed it. For this. For this particular situation. I was ashamed because I fucking knew better.

I knew better than to have sex without a condom when I had no alternative form of birth control. I knew better than to have unprotected sex with someone I wasn’t exclusive with. And deep down, I think I knew he had no intention of becoming exclusive with me.

That last level of awareness is trickier. I have that reflection now, but I can’t put myself back inside the body and headspace of my 24-year-old self and know exactly what I was aware of. But I think I knew.

I was pissed at myself. I had gone to an Ivy League university. I had finished graduate school and was working as a clinician. I talked with people for a living about making adaptive choices, living well, and taking care of themselves. And here I was, buying Plan B because I had put on a performance that went against what I actually wanted and what I valued. It was a performance that put my health and safety at risk, my preferences second, and my honest hopes last.

I did it anyway, fully conscious and fully consenting. I chose not to use a condom. I chose to let him come inside me, unprotected from pregnancy and STIs. There was no alcohol or drugs involved. No temporary loss of control.

It was the opposite. This was controlled. I was performing. And it was an effective performance of The Cool Girl.

I knew I could go to a pharmacy, pay for Plan B, deal with any discomfort and side effects on my own, and never tell him about it. I knew I could keep rocking with this setup until I got on birth control.

I knew I could stomach the incongruence between what I was doing and what I actually valued in service of the greater “good”: this guy eventually realizing he liked me as much as I liked him. If I just performed that well, it would all work out.

But before he fell for me, fully and completely, rom-com style, I fell out of character.

My parents came to visit me from Las Vegas for a long weekend, and I went off script. I asked for something I wanted. I asked him to join us for drinks one evening.

That was when the whole thing came crashing down.

Meeting my parents was more than having a couple of drinks. It was a request for something I had spent our time together pretending I didn’t want: a relationship.

I asked for it in a roundabout but obvious way: meeting the parents. I texted him the invitation and received a palpably long silence. One of those silences your girlfriends explain away with, “Oh, he’s probably just busy. Don’t worry about it. He’s TOTALLY into you.”

But you know. You know the silence has lasted too long. You know he usually responds faster than this. Eventually, he responded and declined.

He declined not just those drinks, but all the future drinks. He liked me, he said, but he didn’t want a relationship.

To his credit, he knew what that invitation meant and didn’t keep pretending otherwise. The fourth wall had been broken. I couldn’t go back to performing the girl who wanted nothing from him, and he could no longer remain oblivious to the fact that I did.

He was decent. He ended things, and that was that. And I was really sad.

I had told my parents about this guy, and now he wasn’t going to meet us for drinks. I was embarrassed. So I had to sit across from them and put on a different performance: The girl who hadn’t really liked him that much in the first place. The girl who was totally fine.

I sucked at that performance.

Authenticity and Appearance

The Cool Girl was a performance.

Women are performing constantly, sexually and otherwise, knowingly and unknowingly. Sometimes, like my younger self, we are aware of the performance we are putting on. Other times, the performance is choreographed by the proverbial “man behind the curtain,” and we have no sense of the performance at all.

And the tricky thing about sexual performance is that behavior itself isn’t a clear indicator of performance, and neither is who the behavior is focused on. What is observable is not the marker of performance. What matters is what the behavior is in service of.

When is going along with a partner’s desires in service of your own sexual agency and the sexual connection between the two of you? And when does going along with a partner’s desires diminish your agency in service of a performance?

GGG

I believe in being good, giving, and game (GGG, à la Dan Savage). I believe in being an attentive, generous, reciprocal lover. I believe in being open to trying new things, taking direction and feedback from a partner, and vice versa. I believe making another person happy is a valuable quality in a sexual partner.

None of those beliefs are performative, even though many of the activities that arise from them may be focused on the other person and their pleasure. The distinction lies in the impetus. Why am I behaving this way? What is driving me to do these things?

Sexual agency does not mean asking, What do I get out of this? before every sexual act. It is not about ruthless self-interest. Generosity can be authentic. Giving can be authentic. Compromise can be authentic. Trying something because your partner loves it can be authentic. Doing something primarily for another person can be deeply authentic.

The performance begins when you disappear from the equation. When your wants, values, boundaries, or preferences become expendable in pursuit of another outcome: being wanted, chosen, loved, perceived as sexy, easy, accommodating, or cool.

In kink dynamics, for example, people can engage in literal “performances,” and the seemingly outlandish roles they take on during a scene can be some of the most authentic versions of themselves, despite the fact that they are literally playing a character. Meanwhile, a woman behaving in a societally ordinary, mundane manner can be entirely absent from herself, performing a character that is deeply upsetting to her and rooted in trauma or fear.

You can’t identify performance by the behavior. You can only identify it by the inner source of that behavior. And because of that proverbial man behind the curtain, sometimes even we can’t tell.

How Do We Know the Difference?

The difference isn’t in what you’re doing. It’s in whether you’re still being true to yourself while you’re doing it.

Women aren’t only performing because we consciously want approval. We perform because some of these scripts were handed to us so early, and rehearsed so often, that they can feel like our authentic selves. Deciphering our own wants from the wants we’ve learned to wear as masks can be almost impossible.

Let’s Take Blow Jobs. The thought process around giving blow jobs might go a little something like this…

Do I actually like giving blow jobs, or is it another version of subjugation that keeps women down? Wait, but women are allowed, and now encouraged, to demand oral sex. Is it a double standard if I don’t want to give head, but I want my partner to go down on me? But I think I do like giving head. It makes him happy. That’s nice. But wait, that blow job isn’t about my pleasure at all, so how could I like it? Does that make me less of a feminist? But I like that it makes him happy. I’m GGG. Do I really like it, or have I been brainwashed?

It’s no wonder we’re confused. It’s no wonder there is infighting within feminist circles about whether we can truly enjoy giving head. The difference between what we actually want and what we’ve learned to want can be nearly imperceptible.

I like being GGG. I like going down on my partner. I like hearing him moan. I like experiencing his pleasure. I’m not doing it because I think I should. I’m doing it because I want to, because I am respected in our relationship, and because there is safety, consent, trust, play, and connection.

But the blow jobs I was giving when I was performing The Cool Girl are pretty much the same blow jobs I’m giving today (plus a few tricks I picked up along the way) as an authentically sexually confident and cool girl.

The behavior looks the same, but I know the difference. The experiences could not be more disparate. The emotional, psychological, and visceral memories are so distinct they might as well belong to two different Carolines. But they don’t. They were both me. One authentic, one not. One confident, one not. One comfortable, one not. One true to herself, and one performing.

It’s not the actions that define the performance. And it’s not even who is receiving or experiencing the pleasure. It’s about values. It’s about whether you are still there inside the experience, being true to yourself. Not the version of yourself you want your partner to see. Not the version culture taught you was sexy. The ruthlessly honest version of yourself, the raw insides that only you and your journal see.

That’s where the performance, or lack thereof, lies.

No one else can tell you; only you can know. But you may have to dig through a lifetime of scripts before you can clearly see the person who picked them up in the first place.

Previous
Previous

Pleasure: The Sex Wasn’t Hot. The Pleasure Was. What psychedelics can teach us about sexual pleasure, context, and why orgasm isn't the whole story

Next
Next

Power: Who Does Your Sexuality Belong To?