Pleasure: The Sex Wasn’t Hot. The Pleasure Was. What psychedelics can teach us about sexual pleasure, context, and why orgasm isn't the whole story

It was not hot.

That first time having sex after the birth of our first child. Decidedly not hot.

It was not rough or sultry or sweaty. It was not throw-down-and-ravish-one-another-all-night sex. It was neither carefree nor loose. It was not tantalizing and teasing and overtaking. It was not sweet caressing or torrid fucking. It was not the stuff of porn or OnlyFans or Reddit.

It was controlled, hesitant, restrained. It was careful.

Given my body’s rough postpartum condition, it was anything but free. It was slow and steady and deliberate. There was no penetration, and very little stimulation of any kind, for me at least. My nipples were chafed. My stitches had not yet dissolved. My boobs were uneven and bumpy. My stomach was tender and soft. I was sore and tired and hormonal.

My body was mine, but I no longer knew my way around it.

I’ve had lots of pleasurable sex. The kind of pleasurable sex one typically thinks of: the wild, free, rip-each-other’s-clothes-off-and-devour-each-other sex. That afternoon was not that. I had no orgasm. There were no handcuffs, no swings, no ravishing, no wildness excavated from deep within.

But that afternoon was one of the most pleasurable sexual experiences of my life. Twelve years later, it still haunts me.

It was ordinary. No, that’s wrong. It was worse than ordinary. Not even a few pumps of missionary. Just me and my husband, exhausted, petrified of what our lives had become, uncertain of our future as parents, coming back together like newlyweds reunited after the war.

I initiated sex that afternoon after the baby went down for a nap, a nap I desperately hoped would last longer than fifteen minutes. I needed him. I needed sex with him. I needed the pleasure of whatever was possible between us. I had no idea what that might be exactly, but I needed to try. I desperately wanted to try.

He was gentle and methodical. He knew I couldn’t do much. He knew there was very little surface area on my body he could even touch without causing pain. And I knew I couldn’t do much at all.

Where could he touch? How much pressure could he use? What was okay? This man I had been having sex with for six years needed a guided tour of my new body, a body I had yet to take a self-guided tour of. Neither of us knew what we were doing, and neither of us felt confident in the mission.

We moved slowly, doing what revealed itself as possible, continuing only with what felt good.

We kissed as we lay next to one another. I was still in a bra and panties, stretchy pants and a nursing shirt, layers protecting my injured flesh. He grabbed my butt, one of the only parts of me where he could apply pressure without causing pain. It was as if that one spot, along with my lips, could still access my sexual agency and pleasure.

Every other inch of me was now dedicated to serving our baby or serving my healing.

It felt like some sort of sick evolutionary joke, so much of the body associated with women’s sexual pleasure altered by childbirth. Like Darwin, the patriarchy, and religion had joined forces and said, “We’ll give her a child, and in doing so, we’ll strip her of her sexuality. We’ll alter her sexual organs in such a way as to ensure she never seeks pleasure again.”

But the cruel joke didn’t land. I didn’t laugh. I was determined to maintain myself, my many selves, even in that altered state. Because the changes I experienced, and that so many women experience, were neither permanent nor powerful enough to squelch the seat of my sexuality, my capacity for desire. My sexual organs might have taken on temporary assignments elsewhere, but desire remained.

That afternoon, we kissed and gently touched. I went down on my husband, carefully contorting my body on the bed so I wouldn’t put pressure on my aching boobs or tender stomach. We were both nervous. But he slowly relaxed into the pleasure of my mouth while I relaxed into the pleasure of our connection. He had an orgasm and I did not. But, as the saying goes, his pleasure was all mine.

Despite the dense fog of hormonal chaos and sleep deprivation, the details of that afternoon remain clear. Pleasure is the best word I have for it, and an ahhhhhh exhale, the best onomatopoeia. It was real and true and intimate and erotic. It was not tantric or multiorgasmic. It was nothing like conventional pleasure, but it was full pleasure.

The Mechanisms

Pleasure is the most obvious concept within my framework of Female Sexual Desire: Permission, Power, Performance, Pleasure, and Play. The idea of pleasure as it pertains to sexual agency feels pretty apparent, pedestrian even. Like, duh, sex should be pleasurable, move on. Even shitty pizza is still good pizza. But I disagree.

It is only obvious if pleasure is narrowly defined by orgasm. We quickly link, if not equate, pleasure with orgasm. Yes, there might be a climax at the end of an encounter, but pleasure can still be absent from an orgasmic experience.

Orgasm can bring relief, but that doesn’t mean it brings pleasure. Sex can lack an orgasm and be immensely pleasurable, like that afternoon in late 2014. Conversely, I can think of times when I had an orgasm and was left feeling anything but pleasure. Some release, maybe. Brief satisfaction. But not pleasure.

Sex and orgasm can be purely functional. It’s a sadly common story women share around the happy hour table: “Yeah, I make my grocery list while I wait for him to finish.” There is no pleasure to be found in that story. And even the, “I did come, but it wasn’t good. It was a few quakes, enough to take my mind off dinner for a few seconds, but the way he does that thing with his finger. Why does he do that? It’s weird.” There’s not a lot of pleasure there either.

Pleasure goes well beyond the presence of orgasm, well beyond the physical conditions of arousal. Pleasure is an experience encompassing our thoughts, feelings, bodies, relationships, and surroundings. It can be fleeting, expansive, relational, solitary, emotional, erotic, soothing, intense, playful, or transcendent.

It’s all in the context.

Let’s Talk About Drugs

The idea of set and setting emerged from psychedelic research in the mid-twentieth century and was popularized by psychologist Timothy Leary and his colleagues in the 1960s.¹ The premise was that the effects of psychedelics could not be understood through the drug alone. The experience was influenced by the person taking it and the context in which it was taken. “Set” referred to the internal state a person brought into the experience, including mood, expectations, fears, intentions, and personality. “Setting” encompassed the physical, social, and cultural environment surrounding them.¹

Psychiatrist Stanislav Grof described LSD as a “nonspecific amplifier of the unconscious.”² The idea wasn’t that psychedelics reliably made you happy, relaxed, sad, or numb. Rather, they could amplify and alter what was already happening within and around you. Neuroscience has given us different language for some of these concepts, describing classic psychedelics as altering communication across brain networks, disrupting some of the brain’s usual patterns while increasing connectivity between networks that are typically more segregated.³

This helps explain why context matters so much. Anxiety, fear, expectation, interpersonal dynamics, noise, unfamiliar surroundings, and a sense of safety can all shape the psychedelic experience. An uncomfortable set or setting can contribute to an intensely distressing experience, while a supportive, intentional environment can help create conditions for experiences people describe as meaningful, therapeutic, or spiritual.⁴ The drug matters enormously, of course. But the drug does not act in isolation.

Pleasure Is Set & Setting

I am not the first person, nor the thousandth, to compare sex to a drug. We talk about being addicted to sex, chasing the high, craving another person, getting our fix. But I don’t think sex itself is the drug in this analogy. It’s the pleasure, the anticipation, the reward, the wanting, and everything we experience around it.

Sexual pleasure, I would argue, has its own set and setting. It is not static, nor is it generated by our sexual organs alone. Our experience of pleasure shifts with what is happening inside us and around us: our thoughts, emotions, expectations, sense of safety, relationship, culture, environment, and the meaning we give to the sexual experience. Research on human sexuality increasingly reflects this biopsychosocial understanding, recognizing sexual experience as an interplay of biological, psychological, relational, social, and cultural factors.⁵

Pleasure, then, is profoundly contextual. It exists beyond the mechanics of our sexual organs and their functioning. Love, intimacy, connection, kink, desire, fantasy, freedom, consent, taboo, pain, power dynamics, surprise, discovery, and more can all shape what pleasure becomes. Put those ingredients inside an environment of safety and sexual freedom, and, well, you’ve got the makings of a pretty good time.

About That Not-Hot Sex…

Because pleasure has its own set and setting, that afternoon a week or so after giving birth was very hot, just not traditionally so. It was wildly pleasurable. It brought me back to myself as a woman, a sexual being, and a lover. It reminded me who I was in addition to being a mother. It allowed me to stay centered and grounded, and for my husband and me to stay connected to each other amid the chaos of the new identities we had just taken on.

The right set and setting didn’t mean a perfectly relaxed mental state, balanced hormones, quality sleep, or a clean, peaceful home. To anyone else, the conditions of that afternoon might have looked ripe for a bad trip.

But for me, they were just right. I was full of desire: to meet my own sexual needs, to connect with my partner, to destress, to feel like myself, to be intimate, to please someone else, to connect. The setting was safe, loving, and secure. I could be wrecked and ravaged and still present myself to this man in my full vulnerability, and be met with desire, care, and generosity.

The set and setting were exactly right.

What Does This Mean for You?

If you’ve read anything else of mine, you know I’m always going to return to hope. I’m also not going to give you a three-step process for inviting pleasure back into your sex life. Sorry, I think it’s more nuanced than that.

I believe our capacity for sexual pleasure is often far greater than the pleasure we currently have access to. But if pleasure is a matter of set and setting, frankly, sometimes life really sucks at creating the conditions for either. Sometimes our internal state and external environment are so far from conducive to pleasure, so actively antagonistic to it, that pleasure can feel impossible to access. Or worse, dead.

It’s as if the routes to your pleasure have been painted over, like old Renaissance canvases used again and again, each new painting burying the one beneath it. There is still something underneath, but accessing it might require carefully peeling back layer after layer to discover what has survived, what has changed, and what is waiting to be seen.

Creating Access

Pleasure is an access process. What is happening within us: our mood, sense of safety and security, values, self-awareness, body image, sleep, and everything else we carry into a sexual experience? And what is happening around us: the structure of our relationship, our communication, the physical space, our cultural context, trauma, and the external messages shaping our permission to experience pleasure?

Are you having the kind of sex you want? Are you sharing what you want with your partner? Are you continuing to see your partner, even after decades together, as an evolving, changeable being, someone you get to continue discovering and knowing, and them, you? Are you experimenting, bringing nuance and novelty into your love? Are you saying, You are safe, and you still have pieces I have yet to know. Are you saying, There are still pieces of me you get to discover? Have you unshackled yourself from patriarchy, restrictive religious teachings, wellness culture, and all the other messages inhibiting your right to pleasure? Have you taken a self-guided tour of your body? Have you taken your pleasure as seriously as you have motherhood, your relationship, your career, your friendships, your fitness routine, or your social media accounts?

Pleasure is ours for the taking, so let’s try not to have bad trips. Create the conditions that give you access to pleasure, whatever those conditions look like for you. Go somewhere else for a moment. Then return with that starry gaze and the wooooah that lingers in the air because no words can quite capture the experience of leaving this world for a moment and returning to reality not quite the same, but maybe a little more free.

Footnotes:

1. Hartogsohn, I. (2017). “Constructing drug effects: A history of set and setting.” Drug Science, Policy and Law, 3, 1–17. This historical review traces the development of the concepts of set and setting and their popularization by Timothy Leary and colleagues in the 1960s.

2. Grof, S. (1980). LSD Psychotherapy. Hunter House. Grof, a psychiatrist and early LSD researcher, characterized LSD as a “nonspecific amplifier” and emphasized its capacity to intensify psychological material rather than produce one uniform psychological state.

3. Girn, M., Doss, M. K., Roseman, L., et al. (2026). “An international mega-analysis of psychedelic drug effects on brain circuit function.” Nature Medicine, 32, 1543–1554. This large analysis combined 11 neuroimaging datasets across LSD, psilocybin, mescaline, DMT, and ayahuasca and found a common pattern of altered large-scale brain organization, particularly increased connectivity between normally more distinct higher-order and sensory networks.

4. Carhart-Harris, R. L., Roseman, L., Haijen, E., et al. (2018). “Psychedelics and the essential importance of context.” Journal of Psychopharmacology, 32(7), 725–731. The authors argue that psychological and environmental context is integral to psychedelic effects and particularly important in therapeutic applications.

5. Laan, E. T. M., Klein, V., Werner, M. A., van Lunsen, R. H. W., & Janssen, E. (2021). “In Pursuit of Pleasure: A Biopsychosocial Perspective on Sexual Pleasure and Gender.” International Journal of Sexual Health, 33(4), 516–536. The authors examine sexual pleasure through a biopsychosocial framework and argue that biological capacity alone cannot explain differences in experienced sexual pleasure; psychological, relational, social, and cultural conditions substantially shape opportunities for pleasure.

***This essay is part of a series exploring the Five Elements of Female Sexuality. If you enjoyed it, you can find the first few in the series in my most recent articles. Pleasure is coming next.

The Five Elements are:

Permission: Permission is the foundation of our sexual agency. Women have never been given permission, not only to experience desire, but to embrace it as legitimate, valuable, healthy, and worthy of pursuit. Permission invites us to reclaim what has always been ours: the right to desire. Question: Am I allowed to want?

Power: Sexual agency is an expression of personal power. Power means recognizing that our sexuality belongs to us, not to our partner, society, religion, or cultural expectations. It is ours to define, communicate, and embody. Question: Can I choose?

Performance: How much of our sexuality is authentically ours, and how much is something we’ve learned to perform? Performance invites us to distinguish between the sexual responses, behaviors, and personas we’ve adopted to meet external expectations and the sexuality that genuinely reflects who we are. Question: Is this actually mine?

Pleasure: Pleasure is more than orgasm. It is our relationship with our bodies, our capacity to receive, and our ability to experience sexuality as something that nourishes us. Pleasure asks whether we have created the safety, connection, and embodiment needed to fully experience our own desire. Question: What feels good?

Play: Play reconnects us with our innate nature. It is the freedom to explore, experiment, imagine, and express ourselves without fear. Like all mammals, we are wired for play. In sexuality, play creates the safety for curiosity, risk-taking, spontaneity, and joy to flourish. Question: What becomes possible?

Previous
Previous

Play: Sex Is One of the Last Places We Get to Be Wild. Why adult play matters more than we think

Next
Next

Performance: Is My Sexual Desire Actually Mine? The sexual scripts we mistake for our own desires