Sorry I Said “Sorry” After Sex. What I Meant Was “You're Welcome.” What squirting taught me about the rule-breaking women who came before me.

Yesterday afternoon, my husband and I had sex. Fun, confetti, playful sex. Not staring deeply into one another’s eyes, more of a lighthearted romp. Not too long or too short, just right. The kind of sex Goldilocks would approve of.

As we lay there afterward, a little sweaty and out of breath, each of us physically and emotionally satiated, I did a thing I wish I hadn’t. A thing that, until recently, I had no awareness I was doing. But upon reflection, it’s something I’ve been doing for years, maybe a decade. After sex, I say one word. An utterance, a tic, a reflexive, involuntary sound that happens to be shaped into the word “Sorry.”

Naked, heart rates still elevated and limbs twisted, I peel my body from his and say, “Sorry.” It’s the same apology I’ve made hundreds of times in moments just like this one, right before getting dressed and returning to laundry or cooking or shuttling a child to a birthday party or basketball game. It’s an apology to a man who, if you’re a regular reader of my newsletter, you know I have an ineffable love and lust for, and he for me. He sees my sexual aura as limitless and tantalizing at even the most mundane moments of the day, in even the frumpiest of sweatpants. It’s an apology he certainly doesn’t need.

It goes:

“Sorry, babe,” I say.

“Don’t be sorry, it’s hot!” he says.

“OK,” I say with a half-smile, acknowledging that I should know this by now. But I still say it, accompanied by a look of gratitude for engaging in this little dance we do each time, a dance we’ve perfected. A dance that reminds me it’s hot, I’m hot, and it’s no bother.

What am I sorry for?

I’m sorry for squirting.

Well, not so much for the squirting, but for the mess the squirting creates. But even then, it’s not much of a mess after getting a waterproof blanket about a year ago. Nevertheless, the “sorry” persists.

But I’m not actually sorry. Or rather, I’M not the one who’s sorry. “I’m sorry” aren’t words that belong to me. They come from my mouth, but they aren’t mine. They are my mother’s, my grandmother’s, her mother’s, and her mother’s before her. “I’m sorry” is an epigenetic marker, a generational trauma passed down over time, living within my core composition. It’s Mendel’s pea plants in the form of an apology, residing solely on the X chromosome, passed from woman to woman, never recessive, always dominant.

“I’m sorry” are the only words available in my post-squirting sex lexicon. As we both lie there, I see the mess on the blanket caused by my orgasm, and “I’m sorry” escapes my mouth. There’s no justification of the mess that perhaps procreation or a man's orgasm would validate. This mess is solely female, solely pleasure-focused.

And so, like the fucked-up version of the patriarchy’s post-nut clarity for women, “I’m sorry” flies out of my mouth before I can even consciously experience it. I must be brought back down to my place. I was elevated too high, lying there being serviced by a man, making a mess that has no productive purpose. So a quick, reflexive “I’m sorry” will reposition me where I belong.

But the thing is, I’m not sorry. And my husband doesn’t want me to be sorry. In fact, he wants me to rejoice in the mess, brag about it, and write about it.

The “Squirting Sorry”

Most of us have our own version of the squirting sorry.

“Sorry, I didn’t respond sooner.”

“Sorry, I was feeding my baby in public.”

“Sorry, I stepped in line before you arrived.”

“Sorry, I was supposed to be seen and not heard, and I shifted in my chair.”

“Sorry, I was taking up more oxygen in this space than you allocated to me.”

“Sorry…”

Despite advances in equality (albeit riddled with fits and starts), women still carry these “sorrys” in our careers, homes, relationships, and bedrooms. Women still contort themselves to catch the glow of the male gaze and navigate a society that places constraints on what is acceptable for us. We do as we’re told, play the parts we’re expected to play, and carry on as if what is happening is totally our idea.

In my individual, micro sexual experiences, I am respected, prioritized, empowered, and pleased. I am an equal.

But in the macro, I still carry the hereditary code. I still carry the dominant apologetic gene. In the throes of a sexual encounter, I can suppress the gene, luxuriating in my desires, fully pursuing pleasure and play. I am empowered and need not justify pleasure or desire with a rationale that makes it about someone or something else. But in the immediate aftermath, before executive function turns back on and my higher-order thinking asserts itself, the utterance of “I’m sorry” expresses my inheritance.

I know I’m not alone.

Maybe your reflex isn’t “I’m sorry.” Maybe it’s “I’m fine” or “No, you have the last slice” or “I’ll pass, I’m trying to be good,” or (my favorite) “I’m just writing to ask if maybe it’s possible…” It’s your language of self-diminishment.

Whatever your “I’m sorry” is, whether it presents itself in the bedroom after you mildly waterboard your husband; or in your softly worded work email; or in the way you (don’t) set boundaries with your in-laws; or in never allowing an unproductive moment to cross your path, as if it were a black cat in your overachieving identity alley, we all have them.

Two Generations of “Sorrys”

When my grandmother died, my mom and her two sisters went through her things. My grandfather had died only a few short months prior, their deaths close together, emblematic of their half-century-plus love story.

As my mom and aunts did the compulsory sorting, they found a stock account in her name, only her name. A tech stock she had purchased early on with a tiny amount of money. A stock that had done nothing but grow. She never withdrew funds, never updated or expanded her portfolio. My mom and aunts were shocked, but oh-so pleased; this discovery posthumously tweaking their narrative of her life story.

She had been a selfless, dutiful wife of a WWII vet, raising three daughters, never working outside the home. She kept this account on the side for years, a badass move worthy of respect.

Only in her death did we see this act of independence. I bet if she were alive when the account was discovered, she would have uttered, “I’m sorry.”

When my mother died, my sisters and I went through her things, and laughed and cried and shared stories. We shared individual stories and the ones where you were all there, but everyone has a completely different take on what happened. I was pregnant with my third child when she died; a circle-of-life moment, I suppose.

She wasn’t a perfect mom; none of us are, but she was mine. She liked her Sauvignon Blanc and could get on a roll at the craps table with the best of them. She liked a stadium hot dog, Cracker Jacks, and Red Vines (not Twizzlers). She wore cardigans with the pearl-beaded buttons and cute little flats with a pop of color. At the end, she switched between two classy sandy-blonde wigs, one short for a typical day, one longer for when she had enough energy to go out. She loved a crisp white blouse and even a set of pearls.

Sometimes she would laugh so loudly it hurt your ears, a boisterous, disturbing-the-people-sitting-next-to-you kind of loud. And in those moments, an “I’m sorry” would reflexively come out of her mouth. She’d be laughing and it would rev up, her loud cackle would escape, she’d try to stifle it, and immediately follow up with “I’m sorry” and a quick cover of her mouth.

I would love to hear her cackle again.

You Only Say “Sorry” After You Break the Rules

These are two “sorry” stories from the two generations of women who came before me. I’m sure there were others.

We all have our “sorrys,” passed down to us through the wrinkled hands of love and the crow’s feet of time. “Sorrys” given from powerful woman to powerful woman. Not a mark of wrongdoing or weakness, but rather, a nod to resilience and will.

For you only say sorry after you break the rules. You only say sorry after you dared to push beyond the walls built to keep you in.

I want to thank these women for their “sorrys,” for their strength to commit the infraction, however minuscule.

I see this fierce willingness to go against the grain today, in my sisters and my daughter. I hear the “sorrys” when my sister puts up a boundary; apologetic, she does it anyway. I hear the “sorry” from my other sister in the way she is ambitious. Not actually sorry, but saying it to manage the emotions of others around her so as not to offend them with her ambition.

What I don’t hear yet is the “sorry” in my daughter. At eight, she is wild and feral, sometimes brushing her hair, but not consistently; sometimes aware of the food on her face, but not always. Sometimes laughing so loudly it scares the dogs.

My favorite moments are when I see her unaware. Swimming in the waves when her bathing suit is twisted; she doesn’t pick or pull at it. She’s completely unbothered, unencumbered by how she is supposed to look.

She is free.

She is not sorry her bathing suit isn’t sitting properly, and I am not about to point it out to her. I’m not telling her to adjust her suit. I’m not sorry for her.

Basking in the Glow

I no longer want to be sorry. I want to thank the generations of women who came before me for their power and beauty and might, for breaking the rules and apologizing after, not asking permission first.

I want to bask in the glow of my sexy mess on our waterproof blanket and rewrite the script. I want to look down at my generous, talented husband’s face, smiling in my delight, relishing in my pleasure, and instead of saying “I’m sorry,” I will choose to say, and eventually reflexively utter:

“You’re welcome.”

Next
Next

The Audacity NOT to Dream. The Intersection of Our Erotic Selves and Possible Selves